For insurers, councils and developers handling claims where a tree is blamed: what a specialist tree lawyer asks before anyone decides the tree has to go.
A property is damaged. An insurer identifies the trees nearby as a possible cause. The tree owner is asked to remove them. Sarah Dodd says she regularly encounters disputes that have run this way, and that by the time her firm becomes involved, positions may have become entrenched. The property owner is understandably worried about their home, the insurer wants to resolve the claim, and the tree owner may be facing the loss of something that has stood for more than a century.
“One of the things that has always struck me about subsidence claims,” she says, “is how quickly the conversation can turn to removing a tree, sometimes before all the available evidence and alternatives have been properly explored.”
The claims are not small ones. Domestic subsidence payouts in the UK reached £307 million in 2025, the highest annual total since the Association of British Insurers began collecting the data in 2017, after a summer the Met Office reported as the UK’s hottest on record.
Sarah is the Founder CEO of Tree Law, which she set up in 2021 and has described as “the UK’s first firm dedicated entirely to tree-related legal issues.” She is a civil and commercial litigator, and the firm works across disputes where a tree is the common element (subsidence, nuisance, planning, enforcement and environmental issues) for insurers, local authorities, businesses and private individuals. Her answer to that pattern starts with the evidence.
Starting with the evidence
“My starting point is always the evidence,” she says. “What is actually causing the damage? How strong is the causal link? What other factors might be involved? And importantly, what are the alternatives?”
“A tree can contribute to subsidence without its removal necessarily being the only reasonable solution,” she says. “I think lawyers have a responsibility to interrogate that properly, rather than simply accepting the first proposed remedy.”
The cases she finds most satisfying are the ones where Tree Law’s involvement changes the nature of the discussion. Instead of simply asking who is liable and whether the tree should go, the questions become how the building can be protected, whether the tree can be retained, and how the competing interests can be reconciled. “That’s where I think specialist legal advice really adds value.”
The same discipline runs through what she writes for councils and large landowners. After a eucalyptus branch in Malaga seriously injured two young women, she wrote that a tree can fail without anyone being negligent, and that in England and Wales the question would be whether the tree owner took reasonable steps to identify and manage a foreseeable risk. “Tree risk management is not just about inspecting trees,” she wrote. “It is about being able to demonstrate that a reasonable system was in place, and that information coming into that system was acted upon.”
None of this means, as she sees it, that the tree should always win.
Both sides of the equation
“I don’t think the answer is that trees should always be saved,” she says. “Nor do I think that buildings should simply be allowed to suffer damage because we want to protect trees.”
What she does think is that people need to stop treating trees as disposable whenever they become inconvenient. “Trees provide enormous benefits, but they can also cause very real problems,” she says. “When a homeowner is dealing with subsidence, it’s frightening, expensive and disruptive. Those concerns deserve to be taken seriously. Equally, removing a mature tree is an irreversible decision with consequences that extend well beyond the individual claim. We need to recognise both sides of that equation.”
For her, the answer lies in better evidence, earlier intervention, more collaboration between professionals and a willingness to consider alternatives. She would like to see lawyers, insurers, engineers, arboriculturists and local authorities working together much earlier in the process.
“Sometimes removal will be justified. Sometimes it won’t. But it should be an informed decision, not a reflex.”
Sarah Dodd, Founder CEO, Tree Law
“I care deeply about trees,” she says, “but I’m a lawyer first, and I believe in evidence, fairness and finding workable solutions.” Much of what she knows about how claims are run, she learned from inside them.
Fourteen years at Eversheds, then a subsidence team
Sarah spent around fourteen years at Eversheds Sutherland, “where I developed my legal career and gained the experience and technical grounding that have stayed with me ever since.” Among the cases her profile lists is Cordin v Newport City Council in the Technology and Construction Court, described there as the first successful Rylands v Fletcher nuisance case since the Second World War.
In 2016 she moved to DAC Beachcroft in Bristol, first managing a team of six lawyers on subrogated recovery claims for UK insurers relating to tree root subsidence, then, from 2020, as partner and head of the subsidence team, leading 15 lawyers acting for UK insurers, the public sector and large corporates. “It gave me the opportunity to lead a subsidence team and develop a much deeper understanding of the insurance industry, how claims are managed and the commercial pressures that influence decision-making,” she says. “I learned an enormous amount, but I also began to see opportunities to approach things differently.” From 2021 to 2023 she also chaired the industry’s Subsidence Forum.
By 2021, she says, she knew she wanted to build something of her own. “It wasn’t that I had fallen out of love with the law. Quite the opposite. I loved the specialist work, but I wanted more freedom to decide how we delivered it, the people we worked with and the wider impact we could have.” She has written that what she did at 45 “still seems nuts when I say it out loud. I started a law firm about trees.”
Starting the firm, she says, was probably the biggest professional test she has faced. “It’s one thing to believe you can do things differently; it’s another to have responsibility for making the business work, supporting a team and ensuring there’s enough work coming through the door.” What she has learned is that “being resilient doesn’t mean never doubting yourself. It means being prepared to keep going, reflect honestly and change course when necessary.”
Five years on, she says, the business has become something broader than she first imagined.
Tools for before a dispute begins
“We’re still lawyers at our core,” she says, “but we’re also developing technology, delivering training, creating opportunities for wider debate and questioning whether the established way of doing things is necessarily the best way.”
Tree Law has developed a carbon calculator designed to help quantify the environmental impact of decisions taken in tree-related claims. With Treelyon, it is developing a digital tree protection and environmental mapping platform, now in soft launch, that brings together datasets which have traditionally sat in different places. It includes Tree Preservation Order data covering more than 75% of England, alongside conservation areas, ancient woodland and registered Biodiversity Net Gain sites, and Wales data is starting to be added.
Tree Law is inviting a small number of housing providers into a free collaborative pilot, starting with around 1,000 properties, to explore what the platform can tell them about protected trees and environmental constraints across a portfolio. She is clear that it is an initial information and planning tool, not a definitive statutory record. “What matters most to us is that the pilot is collaborative,” she wrote.
She also hosts the Trees in a Pod podcast, and followed the Sycamore Gap trial closely, reporting on its implications for tree crime across the national and international press.
“To me, these are all examples of the same thing: trying to use our specialist knowledge to improve how decisions are made, not just advising once a dispute has arisen.”
Sarah, Founder CEO, Tree Law
The biggest change in her, she says, has been “moving from being a lawyer working within a business to being someone who has to think about what a business can contribute to an entire sector.”
Where Sarah Is Now
In October 2026, Tree Law and Sarah were recognised in the Chambers and Partners 2027 rankings. “For a small specialist firm that started five years earlier, that means a great deal,” she says. She was also named in The Lawyer Hot 100 2026, and wrote that she was particularly pleased the write-up focused on Tree Law as a business and on what the team has built. The firm is, in her words, moving “firmly into scale-up mode,” and is recruiting a newly qualified solicitor or experienced legal executive.
The conversations she wants next are with senior decision-makers in insurance, the public sector and property development, organisations dealing with what she calls genuinely difficult and expensive problems involving trees. Most of all, she wants to reach the insurance decision-maker “who recognises that the traditional approach to tree-related claims isn’t always delivering the best outcome, and is prepared to consider something different.” She would also welcome speaking opportunities, collaborations, and conversations with people who wouldn’t ordinarily think of engaging a tree lawyer. More on her speaking and personal work is at sarahdodd.co.uk.
Outside work, she walks, preferably somewhere beautiful, with her husband and their dog. “Being outdoors is where I find perspective, and perhaps it’s no coincidence that I’ve built a career around trees.” She has recently rediscovered journalling and drawing. She turned 50 this year and decided she wanted the next chapter of her life to have “more magic, less noise.” “I think that captures rather well what I’m trying to achieve, both personally and professionally.”
The mantra in her head at the moment, as the firm pushes into a new phase of growth, is “I didn’t come this far just to come this far.” The work itself comes down to one shift. “Ultimately, I want the question to change from ‘How do we get rid of the problem tree?’ to ‘How do we resolve the problem in the best possible way?’”
Five Lines from Sarah’s Diary
“My starting point is always the evidence.”
“A tree can contribute to subsidence without its removal necessarily being the only reasonable solution.”
“We need to stop treating trees as disposable whenever they become inconvenient.”
“Removing a mature tree is an irreversible decision with consequences that extend well beyond the individual claim.”
“Ripping things up and starting again is liberating.”
From the Diary of Sarah Dodd
Sarah Dodd is a UK-based lawyer and the Founder CEO of Tree Law Ltd.
| Role | Founder CEO, Tree Law Ltd |
| Based in | United Kingdom |
| Previously with | DAC Beachcroft LLP (2016 to 2021); Eversheds Sutherland (2002 to 2016) |
| Also | Chairperson, Subsidence Forum (2021 to 2023) |
“Just because we can remove a tree doesn’t necessarily mean that we should.”
Editor’s note
Executives Diary chose Sarah Dodd for the question she puts to the people who run tree claims: what is actually causing the damage, and what are the alternatives. She led a subsidence team acting for UK insurers before founding Tree Law in 2021, and she now builds tools for the stage before a dispute begins. What convinced the editors is that she gives the homeowner’s fear and the century-old tree the same weight in the same answer.
Executives Diary, Editorial



