A former oil and gas HSE manager on what refusing to sign off a major lift taught her about authority, and why quiet people are so often overlooked for leadership.
The project was preparing to lift the roof onto a large condensate storage tank. It was a major milestone, high risk and critical to the schedule. A readiness process had been agreed, and HSE was one of the functions that had to sign off before the lift could go ahead.
Alicia Fuentes wouldn’t sign. There were still outstanding actions, and she wasn’t signing off until they were closed. The construction manager was under pressure to keep the project on schedule, and her project director wasn’t happy about the delay either, although he supported her decision. She explained the risks and what could happen if they proceeded before they were ready, then held her ground. It took a few days for the outstanding actions to be closed satisfactorily. Only then did the lift go ahead.
She had no name for it at the time. Years later she recognised it as Calm Authority, and it became the foundation of her work. Today Alicia is a Quiet Leadership Specialist and the founder and CEO of Alicia Fuentes Coaching and Consultancy in Trinidad and Tobago. She coaches quiet women who want to lead with greater self-trust and authority, whether they’re navigating their own careers and businesses or managing and developing others.
The reader she has most in mind is the person who has begun to believe that being seen as a leader requires a louder, more forceful performance. Quiet Leadership still asks people to stretch: to address a room, challenge decisions, make difficult calls and handle difficult conversations. Her work helps people develop those abilities without treating loudness or performance as the price of entry.
Why Quiet People Get Overlooked
Organisations often overlook their quietest people because they use visibility as evidence of readiness. A quiet employee can keep progressing as an individual contributor, because the quality of her work is easier to see. Nearer to leadership, the assessment shifts to how she communicates, influences and handles pressure. Someone who speaks quickly and projects certainty may look more ready. The quieter person may be thinking just as clearly but expressing it differently, and the organisation may interpret her quietness as hesitation, a lack of confidence or a lack of leadership potential.
Research supports this bias. A 2011 study in the Academy of Management Journal found that extraversion predicts who emerges as a leader and who is judged effective. In its study of pizza stores, leaders rated high in extraversion achieved higher profits when employees were passive, and leaders rated low achieved higher profits when employees were proactive. Extraversion and being quiet are not the same thing, and Alicia is clear on the distinction: Quiet Leadership, as she describes it, isn’t about being introverted or reserved. It’s about how you lead.
One of Alicia’s clients was a quiet employee who had applied for a promotion and didn’t get it. She was told she wasn’t ready, with general references to her attitude and how she handled pressure, and no specific examples or behaviours to work on. Alicia is careful about what she can claim: she cannot honestly say what the successful candidate demonstrated because her client wasn’t given that comparison. However, from the feedback, the organisation appeared to associate readiness with a particular way of displaying confidence and composure under pressure.
She didn’t resign. She stayed and kept doing her work, but she had become despondent and demotivated. The zeal had gone. That was when she decided she needed a coach, and she turned to Alicia. Alicia recognises the pattern from her own career. Alicia worked with her for [THREE MONTHS – NEEDS CONFIRMATION], helping her address the root cause of her old limiting beliefs, recognise her value, set and maintain boundaries, speak so her words landed and advocate for herself. Her improvements were noticed, and she was promoted, her first promotion. More important than the promotion, she came to accept herself as more than enough and deserving of her dreams.
From Oil and Gas to Coaching
Alicia’s career in oil and gas traces a progression from technical expertise to leadership. She joined BG Group in Trinidad and Tobago in 2004 as an HSE Adviser and worked her way to Lead, then Principal HSE Adviser, before becoming a Project HSE Manager in 2013. From 2015 she was Project HSE Manager at Rashpetco, a Shell joint venture in Cairo, where she built a team of eight HSE professionals. From 2020 to 2024 she was HSE System, Planning and Assurance Manager at Shell in Trinidad.
In her earlier years as an individual contributor, she could keep her head down, do the work and deliver. That work eventually earned her promotions and the opportunity to lead people. But leadership changed what was required of her. She had to advocate for her team, address performance, challenge decisions, make difficult calls and become deliberately visible.
At times she tried to meet those expectations by borrowing some of the more forceful behaviours she saw around her. She worked longer, took on more and sometimes agreed when she should have challenged. That kind of performance is draining, and under sustained pressure it becomes difficult to maintain.
She traces how she works to her father. He always said, ‘Where there is a problem, there is a solution, and if there is no solution, there is no problem.’ She’s still not entirely sure the logic holds, but it taught her to keep looking for a way through. He also taught her to document her work so she could see her growth and stand on evidence when challenged.
Her clearest lessons about authority came from construction sites and operating environments.
What Safety Work Taught Her About Authority
In oil and gas, a leadership decision can affect whether work proceeds, whether a critical milestone is delayed and, most importantly, whether people go home safely. The roof lift taught Alicia that authority is tested when the decision is inconvenient. Anyone can uphold a standard when there is no pressure to compromise it. Leadership becomes visible when the schedule is affected, people are unhappy and you still have to make the decision you believe is right.
She could hold her position because her authority had been built long before that day. She spent time in the field, worked closely with the teams and understood the conditions in which they were operating. They had seen her consistency, her competence and her willingness to hold herself accountable too.
In safety leadership, compliance is only the minimum. She needs people to make good decisions when she isn’t standing beside them, and a worker to raise a concern before it becomes an incident, even when speaking up may delay the job or upset someone more senior. That requires psychological safety, and building it meant being there. Being in the trenches with workers helped create that trust.
She checks on the people as carefully as she checks the work. One colleague called her the team’s mother hen, and she chose to take it as a compliment. She learned that rank may secure immediate compliance, but credibility, trust and consistency influence how people behave when the leader is no longer in the room. It is also why her coaching goes beyond helping someone sound more confident.
How Alicia Coaches
When someone comes to Alicia doing good work but receiving little recognition, she doesn’t begin by telling her to speak more, promote herself or create a stakeholder map. Alicia’s Calm Authority Model has three pillars: OWN Your Presence, SPEAK with Impact and STAND in Your Power. She begins with the first.
They start with the meaning the client has attached to being quiet. Alicia asks her to complete a sentence: ‘Being quiet means I am…’ The answers often reveal beliefs the person has carried for years. Then they look at where the belief came from, and whether the person who first gave her that message was making a factual assessment of her ability or expressing a preference for a different kind of person.
From there the client becomes an investigator of her own life. She records in a Leadership Evidence Portfolio, moments when she succeeded, influenced a decision or held her ground. She turns her values into Non-Negotiables, clear standards for how she works, communicates, manages her energy and expects to be treated, and chooses one to practise. The first change Alicia asks her to make is to stop treating her quietness as evidence against herself.
By the end of this foundation, the client has a Quiet Power Identity Statement, a grounded description of who she already is as a leader. Once she has that foundation, they can work on how she speaks, becomes visible and advocates for herself and others. Otherwise, those skills can become another performance she is trying to maintain.
What Changed for One Client
A client came to Alicia deeply uncomfortable with her quiet nature. When someone called her quiet, she felt they were pointing out something wrong with her, and she overthought those moments long afterwards. She preferred to avoid people, felt uncomfortable putting herself forward and sometimes struggled to enjoy time with friends and family because she was so conscious of how she might be perceived.
During the OWN pillar she wrote a Quiet Power Identity Statement: ‘I am a woman who has the courage to go after what she wants. What others underestimate about me are my superpowers. My thoughtfulness, preparation, and consistency are going to bring me my ideal life.’ She returned to it throughout the programme.
In the SPEAK pillar, through Grounded Visibility, she began posting photographs of herself on LinkedIn and agreed to take part in interview sessions where she spoke about her passion for building a personal brand. The strongest shift came through STAND. One of her Non-Negotiables related to how she worked. When she was asked to return to the office, she prepared her case, spoke with her boss and held her position. Alicia used role-play in their sessions so her client could practise the real conversation.
Her boss agreed to let her keep working from home. She now visits the office monthly and feels at ease sharing her ideas, offering suggestions and providing updates during those visits. She is also socialising and hosting gatherings with far more enthusiasm than before.
She remains a quiet, introverted woman. She has expanded what she is willing to do and how confidently she participates. That is how Alicia knows the work has landed.
Where Alicia Is Now
She doesn’t expect this one article to do that on its own. She doesn’t expect it to transform someone’s career or change an organisation’s culture. What she would like it to do is create recognition and curiosity.
For an individual reader, success would be someone thinking, ‘This describes something I’ve experienced but haven’t been able to name.’ She would want that person to become curious about another way of leading, to connect with her and learn more, and perhaps book a free call to explore whether coaching could support them. Her individual coaching currently has a particular focus on quiet women leading teams, but the philosophy of Quiet Leadership is broader than that, so women who aspire to leadership but do not yet lead others can apply quiet leadership too.
For organisational leaders, she wants the article to prompt a different question from HR, learning and development, and senior leaders: have we created such a narrow picture of leadership that we are overlooking valuable people whose authority and contribution show up differently?
Over the next twelve months, reaching further would mean more people finding their way to her coaching, organisations approaching her to explore Quiet Leadership, invitations to write and speak, and growing recognition of Quiet Leadership as a body of work in its own right. She writes Unmuted, a newsletter for capable professionals ready to be seen and recognised as the leaders they already are.
She is building Quiet Leadership into a sustainable body of work through coaching, writing and speaking, while creating a life with more choice, greater harmony and far less hustle. Outside work, she values unhurried time with her husband, her parents and Zoey, her fur baby. Those ordinary moments have become part of the success she no longer wants to postpone.
Alicia’s profile opens and closes on the same line: ‘Quiet is not the opposite of powerful. It never was.’
Five Reflections from Alicia
Finish the sentence. Complete ‘Being quiet means I am…’ and ask where that belief first came from.
Gather the evidence. Write down one moment when you influenced a decision, held your ground or were valued while still being yourself.
Choose a standard. Pick one Non-Negotiable for how you work, and notice when you honour it and when you compromise it.
Look back at the inconvenient decision. Think of a time you had to decide against the schedule, and what you had built beforehand that let you stand behind it.
Check on the people. Ask whether you check on the people as carefully as you check the work.
From the Diary of Alicia Fuentes
Role: Quiet Leadership Specialist | Leadership Coach | Speaker | Facilitator
Based in: Trinidad and Tobago
Previously with: Shell (2020 to 2024), Rashpetco/Shell (2015 to 2020) and BG Group (2004 to 2015)
Also with: Author of the Unmuted newsletter
‘Quiet is not the opposite of powerful. It never was.’
Editor’s Note
Alicia Fuentes comes to leadership coaching from safety leadership in oil and gas, where she held a sign-off that others wanted released. Her account of authority rests on that decision and on what she had built with her teams before it. She is specific about the limits of her claims: she does not say one article will change an organisation, and she says what she cannot know about the clients she describes. Her work is aimed at two readers: the quiet professional who has begun to think she must perform to be taken seriously, and the organisation deciding who counts as ready.
Executives Diary, Editorial


