Melanie Perry: AI Isn’t the Biggest Challenge Facing Entertainment. Human Judgement Is.

Leader in Spotlight

From the Diary of

Melanie Perry

Plenty is said about what AI can do in film and television, and far less about the quality of the decisions about what it should do.

“Technology changes the possibilities. Human judgement determines the standard.”

Melanie Perry on the cover of Executives Diary

“AI slop” has become the shorthand for everything people distrust about generative AI in film, television and advertising. The word has spread far enough that Merriam-Webster’s editors chose slop as their 2025 Word of the Year, defining it as low-quality digital content produced, usually in quantity, by artificial intelligence.

Melanie Perry, a multi award-winning filmmaker and broadcaster who writes about creative leadership in her publication GREENLIT, finds the phrase interesting for another reason. “It is increasingly used as though poor creative work were invented alongside generative AI,” she says. “Anyone who has spent time in entertainment knows that’s nonsense. We’ve been producing dreadful films, forgettable advertising and creatively bankrupt content for decades. Humans were perfectly capable of doing that without a prompt box.”

Humans were perfectly capable of doing that without a prompt box.

On the myth of AI slop

That isn’t to say AI can’t produce poor work. “Clearly it can,” she says. Her point is that poor creative judgement existed long before generative AI, “and we shouldn’t allow our opinions about a particular technology to replace a more rigorous assessment of the actual work.”

The question she’d rather ask is a less comfortable one. “The uncomfortable question is whether the technology is creating poor judgement or simply making existing poor judgement more visible.”

It’s the territory she explores through GREENLIT and her broader work with creative leaders: the human decisions behind AI in film and television, and the assumptions guiding the organisations that make them.

The Assumption Behind the Tools

Melanie Perry speaking at an event in front of a presentation screen
Efficiency is not the same as excellence.

“The most dangerous assumption is that the technology itself determines the quality of the outcome,” Melanie says. “It doesn’t.”

She doesn’t dismiss what AI offers, from faster processes to wider creative possibilities, which she calls “potentially enormous advantages.” “Capability is not the same as creativity. Efficiency is not the same as excellence. And producing more content doesn’t necessarily mean producing anything more valuable.”

What concerns her is how quickly the technology is becoming “a proxy for judgement,” and she sees it happening from two directions. One camp assumes that anything generated with AI must be creatively inferior. The other is so excited by the capabilities that it risks confusing technical achievement with creative achievement. “Both assumptions deserve challenging,” she says.

And the decisions remain human ones. People commission, direct, approve and release the work, she points out, and “the responsibility hasn’t evaporated because a machine became involved.”

The ethical, legal and workforce implications, she adds, “matter enormously.” The BFI’s 2025 report on AI in the screen sector says the UK screen industries of film, high-end television and video games employ more than 200,000 people, and that generative AI could transform how stories are developed, how content is produced and how audiences engage with it.

The question shouldn’t simply be whether AI can produce something. We should ask whether it has creative value, and whether we can stand behind the decisions that produced it.

Melanie Perry, Author, GREENLIT

“Technology changes the possibilities,” she says. “Human judgement determines the standard.”

Judgement, in her experience, is also where talented teams start to drift.

The Questions People Stop Asking

When a talented team begins to drift, the first thing Melanie looks for is “the questions people have stopped asking.”

“In my experience, talented teams can become remarkably effective at maintaining a direction that nobody has seriously questioned for years,” she says. From the outside it looks reassuringly productive. “But activity and progress are not the same thing.”

So she looks at what has become unquestionable: which assumptions are being treated as facts, which decisions are made because “that’s how we do things here,” where genuine discussion has been replaced by polite agreement, and what everybody knows but nobody feels comfortable saying.

“One of the earliest signs of drift is when the cost of challenging a decision starts to feel greater than the cost of making the wrong one,” she says. “That’s a leadership problem.”

Creative industries, she argues, are particularly vulnerable to pressure to conform. “The irony is that we employ exceptionally creative people and then sometimes build environments that reward them for not challenging anything.”

Her answer isn’t endless debate. It’s “the discipline to distinguish between a considered decision and a comfortable habit,” and leaders have to include themselves in that scrutiny.

A team rarely wakes up one morning and decides to become mediocre. More often, it lowers its standards through a thousand small compromises that nobody thinks are worth challenging.

Melanie Perry, Author, GREENLIT

“By the time the results become obvious,” she says, “the drift has usually been happening for some time.” That leaves a harder question: why good people go along with it.

Why Good People Follow Bad Leaders

“Because we frequently underestimate the power of belonging, authority and fear,” Melanie says. People have reputations to protect, and may have invested years in a leader they once believed in. “Bad leadership doesn’t always arrive wearing a villain’s costume,” she says. “Sometimes it arrives dressed as ambition, charisma, certainty or an apparently irresistible vision.”

That’s why she resists the simple division between good people and bad people. Behaviour, in her view, is shaped by what organisations choose to reward or tolerate. “Confidence and competence aren’t interchangeable, and certainty without curiosity can be extraordinarily dangerous.”

Confidence and competence aren’t interchangeable, and certainty without curiosity can be extraordinarily dangerous.

On why good people follow

Some of this comes from her own working life. “Some of the most difficult experiences of my professional life have taught me that being good at your job is not always enough to protect you from poor leadership or unhealthy organisational cultures,” she says. “Rather than allowing those experiences to define the limits of what I could do, I chose to make those questions central to the work I do today.”

In GREENLIT, she says, “I’m not interested in telling readers who the heroes and villains are. I’m interested in giving them better questions to ask.” Why do we reward certain behaviours? What happens to people who disagree? When does loyalty become complicity?

“Good leadership shouldn’t require people to surrender their judgement as the price of belonging,” she says. “And good people shouldn’t have to choose between professional success and personal integrity.”

The questions she asks now have been a long time forming.

The Career Behind the Questions

Melanie doesn’t describe her current focus as a change of direction. “I don’t really see it as a transition,” she says. “I see it as the natural convergence of the things that have interested me throughout my career.”

Early in her career, she worked in executive support at Hitachi Europe. She went on to Henley Management College, to Virgin Healthcare as executive assistant to the CEO, and to The Disney Store’s EMEA business as PA to the Joint MD and SVP Business Operations, where she was also a mentor in the company’s mentoring programme. Alongside that, she chaired the advisory board and the charity committee of Number 42, a Mayfair private members’ club for board-level assistants, and in 2012 founded Heroes On Ice, which produces ice-skating shows for charity.

Melanie Perry standing by a fireplace beneath a crest on a blue wall

In 2018 she became station director and channel owner of The Bucks & Berks Sports Show, and later that year founded Poppy Perry Media. Since then her work has developed across award-winning filmmaking, broadcasting, creative strategy and consultancy. In 2022 she co-founded CR38IVES, a private group connecting professionals across the creative industries.

“I’ve spent years working across marketing, media, broadcasting, creative strategy and communications,” she says. “The common thread has always been the relationship between ideas, people and the decisions that turn one into the other.” Generative AI, she says, has brought some of those questions into particularly sharp focus.

Human Presence and Human Judgement

Melanie Perry standing in a navy suit against a grey studio backdrop
The future needs better judgement, not simply faster adoption or louder opposition.

“I’m not anti-AI,” Melanie says. “Quite the opposite.” She is genuinely excited by the creative possibilities it presents, and very much in favour of intelligent experimentation. “My concern isn’t that organisations are embracing new tools, but that some risk allowing technological enthusiasm, or indeed technological fear, to take the place of independent critical thinking.”

What she’s deeply sceptical of is “the idea that technological sophistication automatically produces better outcomes.”

A system, she says, “cannot assume moral or professional accountability for the consequences of the decisions made around its use. That responsibility remains with us.”

The biggest challenge, she says, is convincing organisations that human judgement is “not simply an additional checkpoint at the end of an automated process. It needs to shape the entire process.” Whose work and rights might be affected? Who is accountable when something goes wrong? “These are leadership decisions, not software settings.”

She is careful about what counts as oversight. Having somebody approve the final output, she says, is not necessarily evidence of meaningful scrutiny. “Human beings are perfectly capable of rubber-stamping poor decisions, especially when the technology appears impressive or the commercial pressure is significant.” What matters, in her view, is “the quality of the decisions being made throughout the process, from the original creative intention to the ethical, commercial and cultural consequences.”

Human presence is not the same as human judgement.

Melanie Perry, Author, GREENLIT

“For me, leadership is about asking better questions, not just retaining human control,” she says. “The future needs better judgement, not simply faster adoption or louder opposition.”

Where Melanie Is Now

Alongside GREENLIT, Melanie is developing The Uncommon Room as “a space for experienced professionals who know the usual answers are no longer enough,” and Slate 38, which she describes as “an emerging concept for deeper executive-level conversations.”

Over the next twelve months she wants to help change the conversation about leadership in entertainment. The reader she most wants to reach is “a senior executive in film, television or entertainment who is commercially successful, understands that the industry is undergoing profound change, but privately suspects that some of the assumptions guiding their organisation are no longer fit for purpose.” That reader, she says, “doesn’t need another person telling them what to think. They need someone prepared to challenge how they think.”

She is looking for strategic advisory work, speaking opportunities and conversations with decision-makers who are prepared to question established thinking. “My ambition isn’t to collect followers who agree with me,” she says.

Underneath all of it is a lesson from early in her career, when she worked for Richard Bromberg, then Head of IT at Hitachi Europe. “I arrived on a temporary contract, having experienced significant workplace bullying in my previous role,” she says. “My professional confidence had been shattered, and I had very little belief in my own abilities.”

Richard kept giving her responsibilities well beyond her comfort zone. When she asked why he kept pushing, the answer came through what he did: “he believed I was capable of far more than I believed myself to be. And he was right.” They’re still in touch today.

“He didn’t simply help me become better at my job,” she says. “He gave me the confidence to believe in my own capabilities, and that influence has stayed with me throughout my career.” For Melanie, that is the real test of leadership. “I believe the legacy of a great leader is measured not just by what they accomplish, but by what other people become capable of accomplishing because of them.”

“That sits at the heart of my philosophy,” she says. “Leave every room and every conversation with the standard a little higher than you found it.”

Leave every room and every conversation with the standard a little higher than you found it.

On the standard she sets

The Playbook

Five Reflections from Melanie

  • What has become unquestionable? Talented teams can keep to a direction nobody has seriously questioned for years and still look busy.
  • What does everybody know but nobody feels comfortable saying? When challenging a decision starts to feel costlier than making the wrong one, that is one of the earliest signs of drift.
  • Does it have creative value? Whether AI can produce something matters less than whether the work has creative value, and whether the decisions that produced it can be stood behind.
  • When does loyalty become complicity? Behaviour is shaped by what organisations choose to reward or tolerate, not only by who is good and who is bad.
  • Who is accountable when something goes wrong? Judgement has to shape the whole process, not wait as a checkpoint at the end of it.

Share post:

Subscribe

Who should be on our next cover? Nominate a leader or yourself for a free feature on Executives Diary.

More Leadership Stories
Related

Darryl Heffline Says the Best Turnarounds Begin Long Before the Numbers Change

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css: Executives Diary Spotlight feature...

You Were Coached on What Not to Say. Nicki Scolaro Bland Thinks That Was the Problem.

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css — Custom CSS...

More Interview Rounds Do Not Equal Less Risk. Corey Babel Explains What They Cost Instead.

Why another round rarely makes a senior hire safer, and what a founder can do instead.