Claire Taylor: “Fix the plumbing and the AI question mostly answers itself”

What has changed in how people find a business online, what hasn’t, and what to check before paying for anything with AI in the name.

An e-commerce business came to TU Marketing this summer with a worry about AI search. ChatGPT wasn’t recommending them.

When the agency looked, the trouble was somewhere else. The business’s security settings were blocking Google’s own crawler. Hundreds of product listings were being rejected because Google couldn’t read them, and several of the most important pages had no description at all. “They were asking about the assistants while the search engine couldn’t get through the front door,” says Claire Taylor, who founded TU Marketing in 2007.

Google’s own guidance on its AI features points the same way. To appear as a supporting link in AI Overviews or AI Mode, a page has to be indexed and eligible to show in Google Search with a snippet, and Google says there are no additional technical requirements.

TU Marketing is a digital marketing agency that runs the marketing for businesses whose owners would rather be running the business. Claire says AI visibility is something she gets asked about a lot at the moment.

Leader in Spotlight: Read Bárbara Salus Feature in Executives Diary

What TU Marketing Does

The agency covers SEO, AI visibility, paid search, social media and content, mostly for engineering, manufacturing, professional services, e-commerce and specialist firms. Claire says it leads with strategy, not channels. “We measure what matters, which usually means enquiries and what they cost, not traffic,” she says, and “we tell the truth, even when it’s uncomfortable, including when the honest answer is that a client should stop spending with us on something.”

What a client feels, she says, is that someone is paying attention to their numbers every week and will say so plainly. They also feel their marketing is in good hands and that they don’t need to worry about it.

Nineteen years in, the team is ten people across the UK, Spain, Poland, India and Canada, run remotely from Spain. There are around two dozen clients, several of them with TU for more than a decade. “What’s changed since 2007 is everything except the job,” she says. Back then it was websites and Google, and now AI assistants have to be added to the mix. “We still exist to make sure a good business gets found by the people looking for it, and that the owner can see whether it’s working.”

When the question is AI, the first thing she looks at is the basics.

Starting With the Basics

Asked why founders who panic about AI search go wrong, Claire’s answer is short: “They skip the boring bit.”

“The founders who panic are usually the ones who never had the fundamentals in place,” she says, “so every new channel feels like starting again.”

Fix the plumbing and the AI question mostly answers itself, because the assistants cite the same well-structured, well-linked, plainly written pages that Google has always rewarded.

Claire Taylor, Founder, TU Marketing

In a recent LinkedIn post she sorted out the acronyms. SEO, she wrote, is how you show up in Google search results, and most buyers still start there. AEO is how you show up when someone asks Google a question and gets an answer at the top of the page. GEO is how you show up when someone asks ChatGPT, Claude or Perplexity to recommend someone in your industry. “Different surface, same principles underneath.” You don’t need three separate strategies, she wrote. You need “one site doing the fundamentals properly, so it can be found on all three.”

She is as direct about her own trade. “I run an agency that sells SEO,” she wrote in another recent post. “I think part of it is finished.” Not all of it, she wrote, and not the part most people assume, but the era when thin content answering common questions could be relied on to bring traffic has gone. Most of what people read on this, she added, comes from people protecting something, so she set out what she actually thinks, “including the bits that are awkward for me.”

Measuring is part of the basics too, and one client’s numbers changed how she reads it.

Customers Nobody Could Trace

Half of one client’s sales, Claire wrote in a recent post, came from people the agency could not trace at all. “Not ‘we lost the source’. No source. Cold, unattributed, straight to buying.”

A few years ago, she wrote, she would have called that a tracking problem. “Now I think it is just what buying looks like.” People do their research “somewhere I cannot see.” They ask ChatGPT who is good at this, read the AI summary at the top of the page and never click through, and check a business out on social media. The first time she sees them is when they arrive ready to buy.

A Pew Research Center analysis of 900 US adults’ browsing in March 2025 found that people who saw an AI summary on Google clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, against 15% for people who didn’t. Fewer rather than none, but the direction is the one she describes.

So the visit she can measure is “the last two seconds of it.” That breaks most reporting, she wrote, because first touch, last touch and the tidy funnel chart all assume the deciding happened somewhere she was allowed to watch.

If the research is happening inside an AI tool, the question is no longer whether you rank. It is whether you are what it says.

Claire, Founder, TU Marketing

Two things follow, in her telling. “Stop grading channels purely on what converts on the click. The thing that did the persuading is usually not the thing that got the credit.” And stop fighting for the click: “Start trying to be the answer.” The cheaper source of evidence, she adds, is the customer. “So many businesses we talk to don’t ask how they found them,” she wrote. “First party data is gold!”

She traces that habit of checking back to her first job.

From Service Secretary to Account Support Manager

Claire started at Herbert Retail in 1997, straight out of college, as a service secretary. She stayed ten years and finished as Account Support Manager. Her profile lists the steps: contracts administration, admin supervisor, manager, commercial, and finally account support. Her clients were the UK’s largest food retailers, and for the last few years she was embedded on site in a major UK supermarket’s IT department, on transformation projects, new store openings and refit programmes.

Asked what the climb taught her that someone who started at the top wouldn’t know, she says it taught her “that the customer’s version of events arrives at the bottom of the building first.” As a service secretary, she says, “you take the call when the promise the sales team made hasn’t been kept, and you learn what ‘done’ actually means to the person paying. Someone who starts at the top never takes that call.”

Everything she cares about at TU comes from that, she says: “the report describes work that actually happened, the number the client sees is the real one, and if we’re behind we say so before they have to ask.” It also gave her “a lasting respect for the people who do the work rather than the people who talk about it, which shapes who I hire.”

The person who shaped how she works, she says, was bizarrely an old peer in that first job. She was in a management role by then, and he wanted her to cover for a mistake he’d made in front of a customer. “I was young and I think he had me down as a pushover.” It was the first time she remembers standing up for herself and saying no, and “it taught me to know my own worth a little more. I’ve never been scared about saying no ever since.”

This August, the numbers in question were TU’s own.

The August Relaunch

In August this year TU relaunched its own website. The redirects from the old pages were wiped, and about a quarter of the agency’s search traffic quietly disappeared. “Nobody noticed for weeks, including me,” Claire says. She found it by reading Search Console “the way I’d read a client’s,” and calls it “a useful reminder that the agency is a client too, and should be treated that way.” TU has “neglected our own marketing for years, which is a real own goal for a business that sells marketing!”

She keeps Friday free of meetings on purpose. “Mon to Thu is for other people’s agendas,” she wrote in a recent post. “Friday is for working on the business. Our own marketing. Writing. Planning. Strategy.” The best decisions she’s made this year, she wrote, “happened on a quiet Friday.”

The day itself starts outdoors.

Where Claire Is Now

This year’s work, in Claire’s account, is AI visibility. It’s what she says she gets asked about a lot at the moment, and it’s what she wants TU to be known for. The article she hopes for is written for the founders of small and mid-sized B2B businesses, the engineering firms, manufacturers, professional services and specialist companies that sell to other businesses. They’re “being told every week that AI has changed everything and that they need to start again,” she says. Most of them, she says, have a website that was built years ago, an agency that sends a report they don’t read, and “a nagging feeling that they can’t tell whether any of it is working.”

What she hopes to give them is “a calmer way to think about it: what has actually changed in how people find things online, what hasn’t, and what to check before they spend a penny on anything with ‘AI’ in the name.” The second reader is the marketing manager inside one of those businesses who has to explain all this to the owner. If it reaches them, she says, it has done its job.

Every day starts outside, with a walk or a run with Darcy, her Spanish rescue dog, and music, an audiobook or a podcast. She’s done it for years. She calls it “my form of meditation” and says she “can’t start the day in the right way without it.”

She also likes creating communities. In the UK it was a running group for women, and in Spain a local hiking group. “I like the idea of having spaces that mix exercise, being outside in nature and socialising too,” she says.

What’s next, in her words: “Being the go-to marketing agency for this AI world that we are living in.”

Claire’s featured post tells of a business owner who said, “We’ve tried everything… SEO, ads, social media… nothing works.” She asked how long they had tried each one. “About three weeks.”

Her line for what she keeps seeing: “Marketing doesn’t usually fail because it doesn’t work. It fails because people stop before it can.”

The Claire Taylor Playbook: What to Check Before You Spend

Give each channel enough time to work. One business owner told her they’d tried SEO, ads and social media and nothing worked. They had given each about three weeks.

Check that Google can get in before you ask about ChatGPT. An e-commerce business was asking about the assistants while its security settings blocked Google’s crawler.

Read your own Search Console the way you’d read a client’s. It’s how she found that about a quarter of TU’s search traffic had gone after the August relaunch.

Ask your customers how they found you. So many businesses TU talks to don’t ask, she wrote, and first party data is gold.

Test your contact form from a personal email, on your phone. Her five-minute test also checks that the notification arrives fast and in the inbox, not junk, and that your reply lands back.

From the Diary of Claire Taylor

Claire Taylor is the Founder of TU Marketing, a digital marketing agency based in Hertfordshire, UK, founded in 2007. She lives in Spain.

RoleFounder, TU Marketing
Based inSpain. TU Marketing is based in Hertfordshire, UK
Previously withHerbert Retail, 1997 to 2007

Marketing doesn’t usually fail because it doesn’t work. It fails because people stop before it can.

Editor’s Note

Founders of small B2B businesses are being told every week that AI search has changed everything. Claire Taylor runs a digital marketing agency founded in 2007, and her answer starts with the basics. The editors chose her because she describes a loss in her own agency’s traffic as plainly as she would a client’s, and because the checks she recommends can be run on any website this week. The piece is written for the owner who can’t tell whether their marketing is working, and for the marketing manager who has to explain it to them.

Executives Diary, Editorial

Share post:

Subscribe

Who should be on our next cover? Nominate a leader or yourself for a free feature on Executives Diary.

More Leadership Stories
Related

Darryl Heffline Says the Best Turnarounds Begin Long Before the Numbers Change

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css: Executives Diary Spotlight feature...

You Were Coached on What Not to Say. Nicki Scolaro Bland Thinks That Was the Problem.

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css — Custom CSS...

More Interview Rounds Do Not Equal Less Risk. Corey Babel Explains What They Cost Instead.

Why another round rarely makes a senior hire safer, and what a founder can do instead.