For anyone doing meaningful work and wondering how to do it differently: why the next move doesn’t need a destination, and what coaching is for besides finding a new job.
In checkers, the pieces move in predictable ways, and getting ahead means moving to the next available square. Chess is a different game. There are more pieces, more possible moves and more than one time horizon, and a move that looks sideways, or even temporarily backward, can create possibilities that weren’t available before.
Careers tend to get planned as checkers. Yet when researchers writing in MIT Sloan Management Review in 2022 studied what kept people at large U.S. companies, they found that providing lateral career opportunities was 2.5 times more powerful than compensation as a predictor of retention. People value the sideways move, even when the plan has no place for it.
The comparison belongs to Gaea Honeycutt, a leadership and executive coach in Alexandria, Virginia, and the founder of Pivot Fairy LLC, who has been writing about it on her blog. She works with people who are, in her words, “already doing meaningful work and are thinking about how they want to do it differently, take on greater responsibility, navigate a transition, or create something new.” And when one of them asks what she would do in their place, she would rather not say.
“People often think they need to know the destination before they can make a move. Sometimes the move itself is how they learn what the destination could be.”
Gaea Honeycutt, Founder and Coach, Pivot Fairy LLC
That idea, and the restraint that goes with it, took her a career in three sectors to arrive at.
Chess, not checkers
“We’re trained to think of career advancement as a climb up the ladder,” Gaea wrote in a recent post. “But sometimes the best move isn’t up. It’s sideways.”
She has a case in mind. A few years ago she worked with a young professional who had been promoted the previous year but not the current one. Rather than focus only on the next promotion, the two of them stepped back and looked at what would make that person more competitive. The questions were plain ones. What competencies have I mastered? Where are my gaps? What experiences would strengthen my positioning? What could I learn in a lateral role that would prepare me for the position I ultimately want?
Early- to mid-career positions, she wrote, can offer the chance to build skills and deepen experience through lateral movement, and those are opportunities that “may be harder to land later.”
None of this is an argument against ambition. It’s an argument about sequence. “The career equivalent is understanding what you’re trying to build, what capabilities or experiences you need, what the environment offers, and what moves create future options,” she says. “And all of that requires truly understanding yourself and what you want.”
That last requirement is where her coaching starts.
The foundation under the goal
“I start by asking what the person wants to focus on, while also exploring what they truly desire and what seems to have their attention,” Gaea says. “Sometimes those aren’t the same thing.” As the two explore, a picture begins to form: what matters to the person, what’s influencing their thinking, what possibilities they’re considering and what may be a barrier. From there, she says, “we can navigate together and begin to identify a path that makes sense for them.”
She learned to look under the request in her consulting days, when clients would come to her asking for one thing and thinking it was a simple resolution. Defining a brand turned out to require understanding how the owner wanted to position the business and themselves. Building a board of advisors meant knowing the mission and vision intimately, and also which characteristics and skills were needed and how they would come together. Government contracting clients and chamber members would tell her their unique selling proposition was being on time, with the work completed on budget.
“Well, that’s what everyone says,” she says. “When you discuss your unique selling proposition, you need to be able to define what’s happening beneath the surface.”
Coaching, as she practices it, “focuses on the foundation beneath the goal just as much as the goal itself.” She wants it seen as a resource for leaders and professionals who are growing, navigating change, making significant decisions or thinking about how they want to lead and work, “not simply as something to turn to when they need to find a new job.” The profession’s own numbers point the same way: in the International Coaching Federation’s 2025 Global Coaching Study, 54% of coaches reported specializing in leadership and executive coaching.
She came to that view by way of a chamber of commerce.
What the Chamber taught her
Gaea’s career spans the federal government, nonprofits, associations and the private sector. She has founded a chamber of commerce and advised businesses, built two mission-driven nonprofits and launched several ventures. Hypatian Institute, the nonprofit she founded in 2015 and chaired until 2023, delivered leadership education to college students and professionals.
The coaching grew out of that work. “My experience with coaching developed out of earlier work where I was often a combination of coach, advisor and mentor,” she says. “At the chamber, people frequently sought me out specifically for advice.”
Leading the Chamber also taught her something about her own speed. She plans and thinks things through quickly. Some board members needed more time to consider the details. “What I viewed as being prepared and helpful, was sometimes experienced as me already having an opinion before they’d had a chance to think,” she says.
“I had to learn that being ahead of the conversation isn’t necessarily the same thing as being effective in the conversation.”
Gaea, Founder and Coach, Pivot Fairy LLC
“That changed how I work with teams,” she says. Being a better team member, she learned, meant slowing down.
Two people shaped how she works. A small business mentor, she says, “fundamentally changed my understanding of structuring consulting and client relations,” which changed how she relates to others and sets boundaries. And her first boss in government “demonstrated what it really means to think three steps ahead,” which has helped her prepare and anticipate more effectively.
It was in government that her questions became a program.
The question employees didn’t expect
Gaea spent more than four years in the federal government. In her last role there, as a Career Program Manager, she stepped into a new position the agency had established to identify and close professional development gaps among employees at the GS-13 to GS-15 grades, a population whose needs, as she puts it on her profile, ranged from “new employee learning curves to ongoing development to retirement planning.” The role was new, and she was the one who developed and built it in practice. She counts more than 100 hours coaching federal leaders at those grades.
She created a framework that built questions in before and during coaching, questions employees didn’t necessarily expect to be asked about their plans and goals. One of her favorites was, “What would you do if you had no constraints?”
“Sometimes the answer was about something happening in their office; other times, it opened up a much bigger conversation about what they actually wanted for themselves,” she says. “Either way, the coaching session met them where they were.”
The role also required her to help employees understand how systems and processes worked within the agency, and to share resources and opportunities. She developed workshops and newsletters, held office hours and one-on-one meetings, and crafted a strategy for a population with varying professional development goals. It was, she says, work she loved.
“I didn’t fully appreciate the impact of that work until I left,” she says. “People expressed genuine sadness that I was leaving and told me how helpful the program had been to the workforce. I hadn’t expected that.” Their response helped her recognize the value they had found in “having someone create the space, structure and resources for them to think about their own development.”
“And so, I decided to pursue coaching when I left the government.”
The line between advice and coaching
Pivot Fairy dates from September 2025, and Gaea recently completed her Certified Master Coach training. She sees the move as continuous with everything before it. “I’ve spent my career planning, executing and advising, and creating the conditions for other people and organizations to move forward,” she says. “Coaching is the next expression of that.”
What changed is the method. “The biggest adjustment has been drawing a much stronger line between advice and coaching,” she says. At the Chamber, being helpful often meant sharing information, resources and opportunities, or giving someone her best advice. In coaching she takes the ICF principles seriously, and that requires her to be much more mindful about what expertise she brings into the conversation. Even when a client asks her directly, “What would you do?” her instinct now is to help them explore the opportunities and think through what aligns with what they want, rather than make the decision for them.
“That’s not always easy for someone who genuinely likes being helpful,” she says. So she has started building a resource listing for clients, a way to make useful information available without turning the coaching conversation into an advice session. Her experience in government gives her a deep understanding of how systems and processes can affect someone’s options, and there too she keeps the distinction, “between helping someone understand the landscape and telling them which path to take.” She described the shift in a post inviting coaches, managers, consultants and educators to a session on it.
“Coaching asks something different of us. It invites us to slow down, make space for curiosity, and trust the other person’s capacity to discover their own path.”
Gaea, Founder and Coach, Pivot Fairy LLC
She is now taking that conversation to groups.
Where Gaea Is Now
Over the next 12 months, Gaea will be sharpening her focus on leadership and executive coaching, and offering group coaching, facilitation and presentations. The group work already has a shape: The Intentional Edge, a series of free, interactive virtual sessions for coaches and other client-facing professionals, held over morning coffee and kept small. “This isn’t a typical webinar,” she wrote of one. “It’s a coaching conversation.” For individuals, she offers 4-session and 8-session coaching packages, and any client can begin with a complimentary Discovery Call.
The people she wants to hear from are leaders and professionals who are growing, navigating change, making significant decisions, or thinking about how they want to lead and work. What she brings to them is curiosity before expertise. “Intellectual curiosity and asking questions let you learn from people who don’t share your experience, understand situations you haven’t encountered, and bring more to the next interaction because you’ve expanded your own frame of reference,” she says.
She is planning for a long game. “I’m building Pivot Fairy into a long-term endeavor that can grow alongside other work and publishing books,” she says. “And eventually, become something I continue in semi-retirement.” One of those books is a novel she is finishing now.
Which brings her back to her own favorite question. “Don’t wait for the conditions to become perfect before you begin creating the thing you want,” she says. Asked what she would do with no constraints, her answer is to “write on a sunny, warm beach every day.”
“Since that hasn’t been feasible, I carry a notebook in my bag and write whenever I can,” she says. “Also, beaches are impractical for writing.”
Five Lines from Gaea’s Diary
- “Simply taking the next step can uncover new paths to what’s possible.”
- “But sometimes the best move isn’t up. It’s sideways.”
- “What would you do if you had no constraints?”
- “That’s not always easy for someone who genuinely likes being helpful.”
- “Don’t wait for the conditions to become perfect before you begin creating the thing you want.”
From the Diary of Gaea Honeycutt
Gaea Honeycutt is an Alexandria, Virginia-based leadership and executive coach and the founder of Pivot Fairy LLC.
| Role | Founder and Coach, Pivot Fairy LLC |
| Based in | Alexandria, Virginia, United States |
| Previously | Executive Coordinator and Career Program Manager, federal government (2024 to 2025) |
| Also | Founder and Chairman, Hypatian Institute, Inc. (2015 to 2023) |
“Simply taking the next step can uncover new paths to what’s possible.”
Editor’s note
Executives Diary features Gaea Honeycutt because she makes a case about careers that runs against the ladder: the move can come before the destination. What convinces the editors is that she holds herself to the same discipline, keeping back advice she is qualified to give so that the client’s own thinking does the work. Her record across a chamber of commerce, nonprofits and the federal government gives that restraint its weight. She is building Pivot Fairy for the long term and says so plainly.
Executives Diary, Editorial



