Kareem Rogers Asks What Changed Because You Were There

A recruiter and career coach on why the resume gets you the interview, and what the interview is there to decide.

The resume was strong. Kareem Rogers remembers it as “just great.” Then he began asking questions, and the candidate answered most of them the same way: “Just look at my resume.”

Kareem says they decided not to move forward with the application, and the decision shocked the candidate. He had missed what an interview is for. “The resume secured the interview, the interview determined if he was a good candidate for the role,” Kareem says. The answers, and the personality behind them, did the deciding.

Kareem is the Founder of The Fit Recruiter, LLC, a Chicago career coaching business where he writes resumes and prepares job seekers for interviews. He is also a recruiter at UI Health, so, as he has written, “I am on both sides of this table.”

He wrote The Highlight Reel: Lead With Your Best Plays In The Resume, The Interview, & The Room for people who feel they deserved more in their careers but don’t know how to position themselves for the job they want. The readers he has in mind first are job seekers, especially mid-career professionals who feel their resume undersells them.

What the Interview Is Deciding

Strong candidates often list what they did and stop there, Kareem says. The one who wins “tells me what changed because they were in the room.”

A resume can’t show how someone treats the people around them. In the interview, he says, that comes through in how candidates talk about their team, their mistakes, and the people who helped them.

“A great resume tells you what someone has done. It will never tell you how they will treat the people around them.”

Kareem Rogers, Founder, The Fit Recruiter, LLC

Employers do look for the signal on paper. In NACE’s Job Outlook 2025 survey, nearly 80% of responding employers said they seek strong teamwork skills on resumes (the survey asked about college students from the Class of 2025).

What he looks for when he is the one hiring is specific.

From the Hiring Side

“The candidates I want to hire rarely have the longest resume,” Kareem says. “They’re the ones who can say clearly what they did, own what they didn’t know, and ask good questions about the team.”

As a coach, he tells clients what he wishes more candidates knew from his side. Employers aren’t only checking skills. They’re asking, in his words, “will I want to work with this person for years?”

He has also watched candidates accept a first offer without realizing there were two or three additional offers ready if they had negotiated.

With clients, the work begins with a question.

What Changed Because You Were There

The first thing Kareem does with a client is ask, “What changed because you were there?” People usually have outcomes, he says, but don’t realize it, so he asks specific questions to bring them out. He learns as much as he can about the client’s work experience, then uses it to structure the resume and the interview prep.

“Duties tell me the job. Results tell me you.”

Kareem, Founder, The Fit Recruiter, LLC

The structure is the R.E.E.L. Method. Result: lead with the outcome. Environment: what you were working with, so the result has context. Execution: what you personally did. Legacy: what’s still true because of your work.

He has written that most people answer behavioral interview questions in reverse. They spend three minutes on the situation, ramble through what they did, and trail off before they reach the result. “Interviewers lose interest before you get to the point,” he wrote.

One client, a data analyst, came to him with an offer.

The Data Analyst’s Counteroffer

The analyst had received an offer for a new job and felt it was less than his worth. He wanted to negotiate.

Kareem worked with him on the case for a counteroffer. His advice was to compare what the analyst brings against the role’s requirements and use that to justify asking for more. The analyst ended up with a higher offer during negotiations.

On his profile, Kareem says The Fit Recruiter has helped clients land roles with $10K-$50K salary increases.

His own path to this work started with a class he left on the first day.

How He Got Into HR

Kareem has written that he dropped finance on the first day of class. He sat in the room, listened to what the next four years would look like, and knew in his gut it was not for him. “The problem was I had no idea what was me,” he wrote.

He picked something that sounded like it fit and kept moving: business management, then entrepreneurship. It bought him time, he wrote, but it did not answer “what am I actually built for?” Then a mentor, Mark Williams, who looked at how Kareem operated, not just his grades, told him to look at HR or student affairs, work “centered on people.” He chose HR. Years later, he wrote, he is a recruiter, a career coach, and builds his whole practice around that one idea.

What he took from it is that most people are not lost for lack of drive. They can’t see their own strengths clearly, he wrote, because they are too close to them. That is why the right mentor, coach, or manager is worth so much.

“I spent years looking for that mirror. Now I try to be it for other people.”

Kareem, Founder, The Fit Recruiter, LLC

Kareem calls Mark his first career coach and resume writer. They met when Mark was a Career Service Advisor in the Gies College of Business at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. He is now Associate Director of the Stuckert Career Center at the University of Kentucky. Mark, Kareem says, played “a pivotal role” in helping him figure out his career after college and guided him toward becoming a career coach and resume writer. Kareem now does that work for other people.

Where Kareem Is Now

The goal for this feature, Kareem says, is readers for The Highlight Reel first, then clients for The Fit Recruiter. The readers he most wants are job seekers, especially mid-career professionals who feel their resume undersells them, with hiring managers second. What’s next, in his words: “Getting The Highlight REEL into the hands of 1,000 job seekers by the end of the year, and bringing the R.E.E.L. Method into workshops at universities and organizations.”

Outside work, he says, “I have a very active life. I’m a gymrat, martial artist, the president of my Toastmaster club, the founder of a jump rope group called Mad Hops, and a model.” He often uses athletes to push his narratives, and he calls himself “a huge proponent of the Mamba Mentality,” a term popularized by the late basketball legend Kobe Bryant. For Kareem it means “a constant quest to be the best version of oneself,” and he says he works on that through learning, relationship building, and self-reflection.

Asked for the one sentence he wants people to remember him by, Kareem gave this: “Lead with your best plays.”

Five Reflections from Kareem

What changed because you were there? Duties tell the job, and results tell who you are.

What did you personally do? Execution is what you personally did.

What’s still true because of your work? That is Legacy, the last step of the method.

What did you not know? The candidates he wants to hire own what they didn’t know.

What would you ask about the team? Good questions about the team are part of what he looks for.

From the Diary of Kareem Rogers

Kareem Rogers is a Chicago-based career coach and the Founder of The Fit Recruiter, LLC.

RoleFounder, The Fit Recruiter, LLC
Based inChicago, Illinois
AlsoAuthor of The Highlight Reel

“Lead with your best plays.”

Editor’s Note

Executives Diary features Kareem Rogers because he makes one argument from both sides of the hiring table. He coaches job seekers through resumes and interviews, and he works as a recruiter who sits in those interviews. His case is specific: the resume earns the interview, and the interview weighs the answers and the personality behind them. The R.E.E.L. Method is how he turns that case into steps a job seeker can use.

Executives Diary, Editorial

Share post:

Subscribe

Who should be on our next cover? Nominate a leader or yourself for a free feature on Executives Diary.

More Leadership Stories
Related

Darryl Heffline Says the Best Turnarounds Begin Long Before the Numbers Change

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css: Executives Diary Spotlight feature...

You Were Coached on What Not to Say. Nicki Scolaro Bland Thinks That Was the Problem.

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css — Custom CSS...

More Interview Rounds Do Not Equal Less Risk. Corey Babel Explains What They Cost Instead.

Why another round rarely makes a senior hire safer, and what a founder can do instead.