Dana Kaplan Doesn’t Say “You Can Do It”

Leader in Spotlight

From the Diary of

Dana Kaplan

Why a child who has decided they can’t read, write or do math needs evidence before praise, and how the adults around them can help find it.

“YOU are a ROCK STAR! Stay curious, stay compassionate, communicate, and always, always stay outside the box.”

Dana Kaplan on the cover of Executives Diary

The boy had decided he was “bad at reading.” The adults around him meant well, and they told him otherwise. He was “encouraged, praised, reassured,” and repeatedly told, “Look how you’re reading the words!” In fact he was reading every fourth or fifth word, recalling sight words from memory. Every time a book was opened, fear and struggle took over, and both fed the story he had already created: I can’t read.

“What the adults were missing wasn’t effort or love,” says the educator who worked with him. “They were missing the child’s personal evidence of success.”

His is not a rare case. A 2014 study in Psychological Science found that adults gave about twice as much inflated praise to children with low self-esteem, and that those same children, after receiving it, went on to choose the easier task.

Dana Kaplan has spent more than two decades with children who have reached that conclusion about themselves. A former New York City classroom teacher, she is the founder of Developing Empathetic Education with Dana (DEED®), a coaching and consulting practice for neurodiverse and out-of-the-box learners, their families, and the schools and organizations around them. When a child is standing at the edge of something new, she starts with a question. “I don’t want to stand behind them shouting, ‘You can do it!’” she says. “I ALWAYS stand beside them and ask, ‘What do you already know about yourself that proves you’re ready to try?’”

Dana Kaplan in a red dress leaning on a wooden table beside a stack of books on education and parenting
“Reading is my escape, my adventure, and one of my greatest joys”

Collecting the Evidence

With the boy, Dana stopped trying to convince him that he was a reader and started helping him investigate what he could already do. Could he hear the sounds in a word? Recognize a familiar word? Understand a story read aloud? Connect that story to his own life? The answer each time was yes. “Suddenly, THEY had evidence,” she says. They built from there, “one tiny success at a time,” and made each success visible.

The wording mattered. Instead of “See? I told you that you could do it,” she asked, and still asks, “Are you noticing what you just accomplished?” Put that way, the accomplishment belongs to the child and not to the adult doing the encouraging. Eventually the boy’s language moved from “I can’t” to “I READ THE WHOLE PAGE!”

I deeply believe confidence isn’t something we can hand to children through praise. Confidence is built when children accumulate evidence of their own capability.

Dana Kaplan, Educational Consultant & Coach, Developing Empathetic Education with Dana (DEED®)

A child who says out loud what they have accomplished, she says, carries that evidence from earlier successes into new challenges. Getting a child that far begins well before any reading or math.

First, She Gets Curious

Dana Kaplan, founder of DEED®, seated on a studio stool in a black halter top and green trousers
“I want to know the human sitting in front of me.”

When a parent brings her a child who has already decided “I can’t do ______,” Dana doesn’t open with the work. “I’m not pulling out a red pen and trying to prove them wrong,” she says. “I want to know the human sitting in front of me.” So she asks. What makes you laugh? What are you ridiculously good at? What drives you “absolutely bananas”? What do you wish adults understood about you? There is usually some silliness along the way. Before she asks a child to do something uncomfortable, she wants them to know she is not “another adult entering the room to tell them all the things they need to ‘fix.’”

Then the two of them become detectives. “I can’t do math” turns into a set of questions. Is it remembering multiplication facts? Understanding the directions? Working quickly? Getting nervous when everyone else seems to know the answer? Or did one difficult experience become, in her words, “a story you’ve been carrying around about yourself?”

She teaches children to become what she calls “nonjudgmental self-observers,” trading “I’m bad at this” for “Hmmm…this is interesting.” The small sound at the front of that sentence does a lot of work. “Judgment closes the door,” she says. “Curiosity cracks it back open.”

Judgment closes the door. Curiosity cracks it back open.

On curiosity over judgment

Sometimes she adds a challenge: “You keep telling me you can’t do ______. I’m not completely convinced. Should we collect some evidence?” Kids, she notes, usually like proving adults wrong, and that works in her favor.

None of this is about pretending. She says she isn’t interested in teaching children “to plaster positivity over something that genuinely feels hard.” What she wants a child to be able to say is more exact than that.

This is hard for me. I wonder why. I know some things that help me. And I know what I can try next.

Dana Kaplan, Educational Consultant & Coach, DEED®

“I’m not trying to create children who never struggle,” she says. The eye for what sits underneath “I can’t” was trained somewhere specific.

Thirteen Years in a New York City Classroom

Dana started teaching in New York City in 2006 and stayed in the classroom for thirteen years. What those years taught her, she says, was “to notice what we are not discussing.” The child who knows the answer and never raises a hand. The child who needs a bathroom break every time writing begins. The child who can explain a complicated idea brilliantly out loud and freezes when asked to put it on paper. The child who appears “unmotivated” and has spent the whole day working twice as hard as everyone else to keep up.

“Behavior is information,” she says. A classroom would not let her judge a child by one moment. She had to see the whole ecosystem, from friendships, transitions and family dynamics to sleepiness, hunger and embarrassment, plus, by her own count, “approximately 4,782 reactions and responses” to whatever was happening at any given moment.

Dana Kaplan in a royal blue shirt dress leaning against a white wall

So when a parent tells her, “My child won’t write,” she hears a hundred questions. Won’t, or can’t yet? Is it the ideas, the handwriting, perfectionism, fear of being wrong? Did writing become associated with correction instead of expression? “I don’t want to fix the behavior before I understand what the behavior is communicating,” she says.

I don’t want to fix the behavior before I understand what the behavior is communicating.

On what behavior is communicating

The other gift of the classroom, she says, was humility. A teacher can create the most spectacular lesson plan in the world, as she tells it, and then twenty-five human beings walk through the door.

Children taught me that education isn’t something we do to them. It is something we build with them.

Dana Kaplan, Educational Consultant & Coach, DEED®

One of her hardest moments, she says, was realizing that her experience didn’t mean she always knew what a child needed. Learning to admit “I don’t know,” to quiet her own need to fix everything and to “listen more deeply” changed her “as both an educator and a human being.”

She founded DEED® just before the pandemic, and describes herself as a “retired classroom educator turned educator for the world.” The practice now takes in one-to-one coaching and tutoring, in-person and virtual workshops for learners from elementary school through college age and for large organizations, and keynote speaking. She is a certified trauma specialist and has been heard on over 150 podcasts. She has ADHD, which her LinkedIn profile calls her superpower, and she says she is “convicted about releasing stigmas concerning neurodivergent learners.” The record she keeps of all this work is not a set of scores.

The Letters She Keeps

Asked for the evidence that her approach works, Dana points to “hundreds of letters, emails, texts, drawings, and messages” from children and parents over two decades. She has kept them all in a file on her computer. They rarely mention a grade, a test score or a particular lesson.

Children write that they learned how to advocate for themselves, how to ask for help without feeling ashamed, how to disagree without destroying a relationship. Parents describe changes at home: conversations shift, children start using emotional language when they are frustrated, families begin asking different kinds of questions. Some of the most meaningful messages, she says, arrive years later.

“Perhaps the greatest evidence comes when I hear some version of: ‘I still hear your voice in my head,’” she says. “And I always hope what they really mean is that somewhere along the way, my voice became their voice.” The intention, in her telling, was never for a child to always need her. It is for them to handle learning, relationships, conflict and life “without me.”

She credits Maya Angelou with shaping how she works with children. Long after a child forgets the lesson she taught, Dana says, “they will remember whether I made them feel seen, heard, loved, capable, and worthy.”

Where Dana Is Now

Dana has moved back to New York City, the place she calls home, and is working with children and families in person again. She says she is building her “next great adventure in NYC” and “staying wildly curious about what’s possible.”

What she wants from the next twelve months is larger than her own practice. She wants DEED® to become a recognized approach to helping children understand how they learn, and she wants to partner “with schools, organizations, educators, and communities through workshops, professional development, and meaningful conversations.” The readers she most hopes to reach are “school leaders, organizational leaders, educators, and parents who know there must be another way.”

Outside work, there are books. “Reading is my escape, my adventure, and one of my greatest joys,” she says, whether she is on her couch or walking the city with an audiobook.

The conversation she hopes to start comes down to two questions. For more than two decades, she says, she has watched what happens when adults stop asking, “What is wrong with this child?” and begin asking, “What is this child trying to tell us about what they need?”

“That shift can change everything.”

Animated Executives Diary graphic of Dana Kaplan’s vision: an arc from I can’t, the story, to I can, the evidence, through curiosity, evidence and ownership

Five Lines from Dana’s Diary

  • “What is this child trying to tell us about what they need?”
  • “What do you already know about yourself that proves you’re ready to try?”
  • “Are you noticing what you just accomplished?”
  • “What am I not understanding yet?”
  • “What is this child communicating that the rest of us haven’t learned how to see yet?”

Share post:

Subscribe

Who should be on our next cover? Nominate a leader or yourself for a free feature on Executives Diary.

More Leadership Stories
Related

Darryl Heffline Says the Best Turnarounds Begin Long Before the Numbers Change

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css: Executives Diary Spotlight feature...

You Were Coached on What Not to Say. Nicki Scolaro Bland Thinks That Was the Problem.

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css — Custom CSS...

More Interview Rounds Do Not Equal Less Risk. Corey Babel Explains What They Cost Instead.

Why another round rarely makes a senior hire safer, and what a founder can do instead.