Mitch Kelly: Finding the Real Cause Behind Falling Enrolments

Leader in Spotlight

From the Diary of

Mitch Kelly

When enrolments fall, the cause often sits somewhere marketing can’t see. Mitch on how he finds it, and what he does next.

“Most marketing problems in training organisations originate outside of marketing.”

Mitch Kelly on the cover of Executives Diary

The first sign was in Google Ads. Demand from impression-based searches had fallen for key search terms that had been getting a lot of impressions in the prior weeks. When Mitch and his team searched online for the change behind it, they found that the funding for that particular qualification had been removed, which greatly affected demand.

In vocational education and training, he says, three things drive public enrolments: the price of the course, proximity to the facility and availability of scheduled class dates. When one of them breaks, as price did here once the funding subsidy disappeared, “the whole funnel collapses and user behaviour shifts.” His diagnosis was a lack of communication across the organisation. Functions weren’t speaking to each other, when everything needs to be integrated across the business rather than sitting in silos.

Mitch Kelly was the Group CMO at the publicly listed training group at the time. Today he’s the founder of Nectar Agency and a fractional CMO for education and training providers in the UK and registered training organisations (RTOs) in Australia. At a multi-site training business he led marketing for, applications grew by roughly 60% and enquiries nearly tripled, but he looked at the results critically and still took them to leadership as a problem.

Mitch Kelly at the Brave New World event, audience and stage screens behind him

The Weekly Stand-Up

To stop it happening again, the team put a weekly stand-up in place with the other function heads. It stayed on top-level agenda items, and its job was to catch changes like this before they happen, so that marketing spend and messaging can pivot.

He’s written about the pattern since. The symptom shows up in enrolments or leads, he says, but the cause can sit “outside the marketing and business.” Policy, funding and partnership structures are rarely visible to marketing. Looking across functions is also one of the first things he does when he’s engaged as a CMO, even though it’s rarely in the remit.

How Mitch Got Here

He didn’t always see it that way. As a junior, he thought business functions sat in silos and got on with it. A few years in, after being thrown in the deep end in other areas of the business, he understood how big a barrier that was to success.

His MBA at QUT’s (Queensland University of Technology) Graduate School of Business, which included Systems Thinking for Managers, Advanced Strategy and Problem Framing for Creative Action, prepared him for conversations in closed rooms. He received the Dean’s Award for Academic Excellence in 2019.

He has described a key frustration from working agency-side: the pressure to push a channel the client didn’t need, simply to fill a quota and ‘up-sell’ services. That’s why he built the model behind Nectar Agency, which he founded in February 2024, around pivoting across channels based on data and the audience buying behaviours, rather than contracts.

Where he starts when a training provider brings him falling enrolments is specific.

Starting From the Number

Root-cause work starts with the effect, not the environment.

Mitch Kelly, Founder, Nectar Agency

He pins the problem to an actual number that has an impact: enrolments down, cost per enrolment up, a site that won’t break even. Then he looks for where it isn’t happening, “because the comparison is where the cause hides.”

Next, he breaks the numbers into its drivers and looks at the ratios before asking why leads, conversions, course fill rates, price or delivery cost are being affected. When one of those figures points him there, he’ll go wide into the relevant policies, macroenvironment, funding or the market.

That identifies the driver. After it comes a systems question, why might it keep occurring? Most recurring problems in training organisations, he says, aren’t a single cause but a loop. Enrolments dip, so ad spend increases. The extra spend buys lower-intent leads, conversions fall, sales starts discounting courses and margin shrinks. There’s less to invest in the courses employers or students actually want, which might then impact quality. “It’s a bad loop to be stuck in,” he says.

His undergraduate degree in economics trained one habit he relies on constantly: asking what a decision sets in motion after the obvious effect.

The fix that relieves this quarter’s number might be the one creating next year’s problem.

Mitch Kelly, Founder, Nectar Agency

His standing rule is to look for something to disprove his hypothesis rather than prove it, because that’s where it will unravel. He adds: “You need to always be looking at the wider problem that it’s trying to solve, and instead of looking for proof to back your hypothesis, looking for data that disproves it.”

The clearest example he gives of it at work comes from a multi-site training business.

The Multi-Site Business

Mitch led marketing for the business, which had operations in Australia, Asia and the Middle East. Over one to two years, the team rebuilt the digital channels and built a marketing attribution model that showed where high-value conversions were coming from. Applications grew by roughly 60% while enquiries nearly tripled, while reducing marketing capital by 8%.

It was an uphill battle with some stakeholders, he says. The business had a bad reputation in some regions because courses were being cancelled a few days before they were scheduled, and clients who had planned work streams around these training days were being driven to competitors.

At the end of each quarter and FY, an analysis using the P&L for each facility found a clear outlier. One of the most in-demand facilities was running at a profit margin of 2%. With that, the team engaged operations to change how courses and resources were managed, and to propose guarantees on scheduled dates, even if some ran at a loss, because it would maintain client relationships and improve word-of-mouth reputation, which resulted in more bookings long-term. Marketing messaging adapted too, along with positioning around outcomes and industry connections.

As he puts it, “Our best year of student applications was almost a flat year for revenue.” He had to present that to leadership as “a problem, not a win,” and argue for running some courses at a loss to rebuild trust.

Our best year of student applications was almost a flat year for revenue.

On the multi-site training business

He’s clear the result didn’t come from marketing alone. He rates the marketing work and the team behind him highly, but says it came from the wider business working together to communicate the same message. He’s also written that his best marketing decision had nothing to do with marketing: it was learning to read a P&L properly and speak the language of the board.

His work now sits across two systems, the Australian one and the UK one, and he says they buy training differently.

Two Markets, Two Ways of Buying

Mitch Kelly at Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park in London with the ArcelorMittal Orbit behind him
“Building Nectar Agency into a strategic marketing partner for Australian and UK training providers.”

In Australia, a lot of short-course training is bought like a retail product. A worker or a contractor needs a ticket or to renew an existing one to work on a worksite or for a specific employer, and they choose on price, location and the next available date, usually within a couple of weeks of first searching and sometimes only days out. In the UK, far more of the market runs through employer funding, so the buyer is often an HR or L&D manager working within levy rules, and the sale looks more like account management than retail. That’s not to say retail buying behaviour doesn’t exist there too.

Neither model is better, he says. They’re just different, and the communications approach needs to adapt. What working in both regions has shown him is that the funding rulebook can decide the product and consumer behaviour, the buyer and the sales cycle, and that the behaviour shifts depending on the industry and level of course qualification.

England is in the middle of one of those shifts now, he says, with funding opening up to shorter courses and co-investment rising for older apprentices. The government set out the direction in September 2024, announcing that the growth and skills levy would fund shorter apprenticeships, where the existing system required at least 12 months, and that employers would be asked to fund more level 7 apprenticeships outside the levy.

A provider whose marketing is built around the old rules and positioning will see enrolments fall and assume it’s a marketing problem, he says, when it hasn’t been addressed at the operational and organisational level.

Nectar Agency is where he does that work now.

How Nectar Agency Works

As he puts it on his profile, the aim is the high-level strategy of a C-suite executive combined with a flexible execution team, without the overhead of a full-time hire. He’s direct about what a business should look for in a fractional CMO, which is more than marketing skills. They need to understand finance and, more importantly, operations. When business functions are aligned, he’s written, they deliver an experience that reinforces what marketing is positioning the business as, and customers become the growth channel.

He’s also named the framework he uses to define strategy. Rumelt’s kernel has three parts: a clear diagnosis of the actual problem, a guiding policy for how to approach it, and a set of coherent actions that reinforce each other. His test for founders and business managers is whether they can state their business’s diagnosis in one sentence. “Not the goal, but the actual problem.”

Mitch Kelly seated at a table in Brasserie Zédel, London

Not the goal, but the actual problem.

His one-sentence test for founders

He has also built a range of free strategy tools. A business briefs one in about three minutes, and it develops a strategy deck using named frameworks from consulting projects and client work, showing on every slide which model was used, and its workings so the reader can confirm everything is accurate, rather than trust the output blindly, as happens with many AI tools. Running a client’s existing problems through a range of models is typically the first step he takes with business owners and CEOs, he’s written, and the tools are meant to inform a team’s work rather than replace it. He’d rather people try to break them than compliment them, and feedback is always welcome.

Where Mitch Is Now

Mitch’s day-to-day work is fractional CMO engagements. Two of his clients are Link Resources RTO in Australia and Bee N Spired in the UK. Link Resources is an education and training RTO in the resources and safety sector, where he focuses on digital channels, strategy and launching into new markets. Bee N Spired works on student engagement for care experienced individuals through enrichment workshops, and his focus there is SEO, marketing strategy and partnerships. He also works with The Slice Network, a fractional CMO network, as a partner, along with the Portfolio Executive.

Over the next twelve months, he wants to work with more education and training providers as clients for Nectar Agency, more fractional CMO engagements and recognition for the root-cause approach. The readers he most wants to speak with are CEOs and founders of education and training providers in the UK and EU, and of Registered Training Organisations (RTOs) in Australia and New Zealand. He’d also like to hear from directories that speak with them.

Outside work, he’s a rock climber.

I’m a keen rock climber and I use that as a space in my mind to meditate. It’s the only thing that allows me to switch off and be in the moment, you are only thinking about making the next clip or if I fall here what will happen, so it keeps me grounded and helps with problem solving.

Mitch Kelly, Founder, Nectar Agency

What comes next, in his words: “Building Nectar Agency into a strategic marketing partner for Australian and UK training providers.”

Executives Diary animation of Mitch Kelly's vision, from Australia and the United Kingdom to a strategic marketing partner

The Playbook

Five Reflections from Mitch

  • What is the number? Pin the problem to an actual figure that has an impact, such as enrolments down, cost per enrolments up or a site that won’t break even.
  • Where isn’t it happening? The comparison is where the cause hides.
  • Which driver moved? Break the number into leads, conversions, course fill rates, price or delivery cost, and look at the ratios against the P&L or within your own data before asking why.
  • What loop keeps it going? Most recurring problems are less a single cause than a loop, so ask why it might keep occurring.
  • What would disprove your hypothesis? Look for it, because that is where it will unravel, and keep the wider problem in view.

Share post:

Subscribe

Who should be on our next cover? Nominate a leader or yourself for a free feature on Executives Diary.

More Leadership Stories
Related

Darryl Heffline Says the Best Turnarounds Begin Long Before the Numbers Change

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css: Executives Diary Spotlight feature...

You Were Coached on What Not to Say. Nicki Scolaro Bland Thinks That Was the Problem.

/* ==================================================================== ed-feature-paid.css — Custom CSS...

More Interview Rounds Do Not Equal Less Risk. Corey Babel Explains What They Cost Instead.

Why another round rarely makes a senior hire safer, and what a founder can do instead.